Content note: this article includes mention of child suicide.
Appearing before the Education Committee on Wednesday, Education Secretary Lucy Powell said the Government is “working night and day along with our trusted partners” to finalise their SEND reform plans. Chaired by Helen Hayes MP, Ms Powell told fellow MPs they’d have to wait for the Bill—coming early 2027—to find out whether they were planning to drop some of the plans to cut existing SEND rights. It’ll be a surprise gift to get us through those dark and chilly days of the “very early new year”. Can’t wait.
But Bills have to fit into the legislative timetable, so a later Bill—and maintaining the original implementation dates—runs both a risk of running out of time and leaves less time for scrutiny and preparation. Ms Powell seemed unconcerned, emphasising they would take as long as needed to “get it right”
Ms Powell said she expects to publish the “Education for All” Bill containing its proposed SEND legislation along with the long-awaited response to its SEND consultation that closed almost six months ago, its National Inclusion Standards, and its updated approach to Specialist Provision Packages. However, the Secretary had no answer to whether the response to the June EOTAS consultation would come at the same time. She also did not know why there had been two separate consultations.
I know the answer, ask me!
Allow us to help: It’s because her departmental colleagues, armed with five minutes’ experience of the subject they’d been tasked with fixing, knew nothing about EOTAS. Obviously, that lack of knowledge back then wasn’t their fault, but it led, in our May webinar, to SEND Minister Georgia Gould assuring us EOTAS wasn’t in the reform crosshairs. Then she went away and realised 1. What it actually was and 2. That it absolutely had to be included or the entire plan would make no sense whatsoever.
After we and others raised concerns, a separate consultation was announced with plans to make EOTAS a stepping stone back into school, and to allow a random special school to decide if the child could have EOTAS at all, or if they’d have to be forced to attend and never mind the trauma. Understandably, this has sent the EOTAS community into a tailspin of worry. The DfE has subsequently–and sensibly–established an EOTAS group, to which we successfully nominated Megan Booth, SOS!SEN’s EOTAS expert. You can see Megan in action in our EOTAS webinar here.
So we do acknowledge that the DfE is listening to some actual experts in SEND, and changing their proposals as a result. Sadly, all this thinking should have been done before the consultation announced proposals that have caused anxiety and despair. So when they talk about trust–as Ms Powell repeatedly did–they have a long way to go to show us they deserve it, because this isn’t how you treat families who have already lived (and are living) through some of the worst times of their lives.
So, while there was no confirmation of any row back any of plans to decimate SEND legal rights—and to be fair, we didn’t expect any—there was a hint that there may be some concessions. If they do, it’s because of the continuous work that our Save Our Children’s Rights campaign and its many supporters are doing, keeping the pressure and noise up so that, even if Ms Powell doesn’t want to speak to us, our message is being heard.
What happens when an Individual Support Plan fails
During the session, Committee MPs Mark Sewards, Manuela Perteghella and chair Helen Hayes all emphasised that to get real trust from parents, rights cannot be discarded as unnecessary. Darren Paffey MP pressed Ms Powell on building confidence and whether more was needed, she said: “we are getting that buy-in”, something that is difficult to reconcile with our experience. Which voices are being heard, and how are objections to removing rights being addressed?
When MPs asked several times if parents would only be able to get real redress by judicial review (or disability discrimination), Ms Powell dodged the question, repeatedly trotting out the list of promised improvements. The hint of a change came when she said the mechanisms for challenging Individual Support Plans were still being worked through, but offered no actual response to how families would challenge an inappropriate placement if tribunals lost the power to name a specific setting.
At present, children with SEND but without EHCPs have an SEN Support Plan, based around “Assess, Plan, Do, Review”. It’s not statutory, so when the SEND proposals unveiled a legal right to an “Individual Support Plan (ISP) instead, it came as welcome news. But that was until we realised that this “right” to an ISP came with no guarantee that whatever was in it would be useful and no appeal rights. An empty right, if you will.
Mark Sewards asked what right of appeal a parent should have when an ISP dispute remains unresolved after mediation. Ms Powell said this was “the nub” of what ministers were working through, but she preferred to pivot to not needing to complain in the first place– preferable, of course, but not answering the question. She cited an astonishing 80% reduction in speech and language referrals in Rochdale because of an “innovative” offer, reported in a local press article to consist of “artificial intelligence (AI) technology, tailored speech and language advice through WhatsApp, the Help at Hand coaching platform, and an online virtual noticeboard which offers practical tips, resources and activities.”
Not to be sceptical, but we’d like to see an evaluation of this–a decrease in referrals can come for many reasons, including schools being instructed not to refer until they’ve run the gamut of this AI and text-based offering, rather than having an assessment by an actual human. Because if speech and language issues were that easy to fix, we wouldn’t need therapists.
Manuela Perteghella then raised the bureaucratic burden of school complaints procedures and compulsory mediation, and the potential damage to relationships with parents. Powell described these as initial proposals and acknowledged that these concerns were a key consultation theme. That leaves room for change so we shall see where it leads.
Health must deliver support as well as endorse reform
The thorny issue of health involvement has existed since the inception of the 2014 reforms. The NHS has clear duties towards children with SEND, but it seems to think the Children and Families Act does not apply to health bodies. Will these reforms bring them to heel? The Secretary of State said she believed they had health buy-in, but so did we back in 2012 and look what happened.
Given the pressures the NHS is under, not least in autism and ADHD assessment waiting lists (a 6-year-old close relative is on his second year of waiting–how is this acceptable?) I would suggest making the “grit in the oyster” incentive that Ms Powell referred to so uncomfortable that NHS leaders and providers cannot ignore it. They may also need thumb screws. As with local authorities, the problem isn’t just money; it’s culture, and I haven’t heard this mentioned at all. If not tackled at the same time, this will derail everything, just like it did the last time–and that’s not a warning, it’s a prediction.
Related to long waiting lists, Ms Powell also mentioned the aim of not waiting for a diagnosis before providing support. It’s worth reiterating that existing SEN duties are already needs-based: something that seems to be wilfully ignored. I wonder if the SoS has read the current legislation. I would recommend it; it’s already quite comprehensive. Children need those existing duties followed and funded while they wait for assessment–there is nothing in law to stop this happening now. Then all those millions Ms Powell talked about could be used to boost what’s good and fund making accountability really count.
Ms Powell repeatedly cited Experts at Hand. Matt Keer has already examined the specialist workforce shortages that threaten delivery, and my recent article underlined the extent of the workforce shortage as shown by the DfE’s own research. Ms Powell quoted recent statistics showing a decrease in leaders deserting the profession. But it’s not the leaders who provide support at the coal face, or (non-AI) specialist help. And we know from those research surveys how burnt out class teachers are.
Tribunal placement powers remain unresolved
In the short clip below, Manuella Perteghella asks if parents would be left only with judicial review if they had no Tribunal route left. Ms Powell didn’t want to talk about the Tribunal, and asked the committee to wait for the detailed proposals. But Committee Chair Helen Hayes wanted to make sure the point was clearly made. Echoing points we have also made, she said while improving provision should reduce appeals, failings cannot be eradicated.
Existing SEND duties already have the force of law
Towards the end of her answer above, Ms Powell said: “No one’s particularly had a duty to provide it [SEND Provision] properly”. This adds to my suspicion that Ms Powell hasn’t actually read the legislation but is just relying on what she’s been told, because it is a completely inaccurate description of existing law and should have been challenged. The law is, in fact, very clear: Section 42 of the Children and Families Act 2014 requires a council maintaining an EHCP to secure its specified special educational provision. The responsible health body must arrange specified health provision, subject to the exception for suitable alternative arrangements. Section 66 also places a best endeavours duty on mainstream schools and other listed institutions.
Ms Powell, if you remember, was on the 2019 education committee whose 2019 report concluded that the 2014 reforms were the right ones and warned against weakening duties or making fundamental legal changes to fix implementation problems. What’s changed, Lucy?
Ministers already have evidence of the harm
Earlier this year, Measure What Matters published its investigation into children’s deaths and unmet SEND needs on SNJ, alongside family testimonies. The MP Chris Coghlan has been instrumental in bring this to light. Mr Coghlan was quoted in the Independent yesterday about potential criminal prosecutions of public bodies.
“Not only has the government failed to act, but it plans to reduce children’s legal protections from the very institutions causing them harm. I am now working with some of these families on potential criminal prosecutions.”
Hours after the select committee meeting, during Prime Minister’s Questions, Chris asked the Prime Minister (via his stand-in Louise Haigh) for a meeting to discuss these failures. They include the tragic story of Eivie White, an autistic girl with ADHD who died by suicide in March 2023. Her mother, Shelley, told the newspaper, “We trusted the council, the trained professionals to do the right thing and to provide the support Eivie needed.”
Watch his short clip below
In the Independent article, a Measure What Matters spokesperson questioned the absence of automatic scrutiny of SEND compliance triggered specifically by EHCP status when a child dies.
“Accountability for those duties doesn’t end with a child’s death. Yet in Eivie’s case, we have found no evidence that anyone has examined whether they were met.”
Families should not have to enforce the law alone
In September, MWM described its proposed legal challenge to council practices on SNJ. Lawyers would investigate whether internal approvals and commissioning processes were unlawfully determining when children received provision. The aim is to establish grounds for a systemic challenge, rather than leave every family to fight the same practice alone.
Publishing the Bill with its supporting standards should allow informed scrutiny. Ms Powell’s recognition that redress needs attention must now translate into usable protections.
Ms Powell said the worst outcome would be legislation that people did not trust. Trust and confidence—those things they seem to want so much—will require ministers to engage with those challenging the planned loss of rights and act on the failures already documented. We have already seen what happens to LAs that routinely break laws and harm children—not very much at all. If we can’t trust them to punish those who actively hurt children by law-breaking, alleged misconduct, and maladministration, how can we trust them when they threaten to take away those laws?
Do you see why parents have no confidence?
Better mainstream support and effective independent redress can be delivered together. Children should not have to surrender legal protections in return for a promise that, this time, support will arrive. Because, frankly, parents do not believe that it will.
Disabled Children’s Rights are Under Attack.
We’re fighting, but we can’t do it alone: we need your help more than ever.
We’re volunteer-run, but costs are rising. To help us keep going, please consider a one-off or, if it’s possible, a regular donation.
Read more about being a regular donor here.
We use Zeffy to fundraise, which doesn’t charge us a fee, so 100% of your donation reaches us.
Also read:
Don’t miss a thing!
Don’t miss any posts from SNJ – simply add your email address below. You must click the link in the confirmation email you’ll receive to activate your free subscription.
You can also keep up with us by following our
Want more? Be an SNJ regular donor!
SNJ is a non-profit and everyone who writes here does so voluntarily. We need your support to help us with costs by donating once or as a regular patron. Find out more here
- Early 2027 for Education and SEND Bill but how far will the Government row back on rights plans? Parental trust and confidence depend on it - November 5, 2026
- The child behind the symptoms: Why MCAS is being missed in children and young people - October 20, 2026
- The government must not ignore stark warnings about lack of mainstream SEND capacity reported by its own research - October 16, 2026
Discover more from Special Needs Jungle
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.





































