Legal Aid: Judicial Review only for wealthy parents?

When, as a parent, you hold your child’s final statement, complete with acceptable placement in your trembling hand, you may think it’s okay to heave a huge sigh of relief.

Mostly, it is, for a while, but what would you do if you discovered that the provision in the statement wasn’t being delivered to your child?

Of course, you talk to the school. And if no joy, you talk to the local authority’s SEN department.

By this time, something is quite often done about it and if not, you have the threat of Judicial Review (JR) to aim your sights on.

JRUp until now, you could claim legal aid for this if your coffers were empty. But slipping its way through the darkened nights, while we’ve all got our heads buried in the Code of Practice, are government plans to snatch your entitlements from under your very noses.

Think the legal aid changes are done and dusted?  Think again. Now under extended consultation are plans to restrict legal aid in these cases.

Currently, for the most part, if you believe that your local authority is failing in its duties to your child (such as we mentioned earlier, not providing all the elements within a statement or care plan), you can bring legal action against them, with the benefit of legal aid.

An application has to be made to the court for permission to bring this action, then if the court considers there is an arguable case you will get permission to bring the full action. legal aid currently covers the legal costs including the fees for barristers and solicitors as well as any costs which may be claimed by the other side if you lose.

What is being proposed?

Legal aid will still be available but only once an application has been submitted to the court and the court has given permission to bring the full action.

In the majority of cases, there is a clear breach of legal duties, so the cases never get to the stage of asking for JR as the local authority will sort the problem out.  However, sometimes the LA will drag its feet over resolving the issue, unless it knows there is a real risk of legal action being brought.

What do the proposed changes actually mean for me?

With LAs having to cut chunks from their budgets and with much uncertainty in the next year as the Children and Families Bill finalises, there is a real risk of an increase in cases where families will need to seek legal representation and advice.

If the current proposals for legal aid go ahead, then:

  • Lawyers won't be paid for any initial work they do for you
  • Lawyers won't be prepared to take on strong cases (currently resolved before action is taken - so no payment for them)
  • This may leave local authorities tempted to make cuts or take short cuts, knowing it is unlikely to be challenged in court.

So on the face of it, those poor lawyers won’t get paid. How sad. But on the other hand, if they don’t get paid they are quite likely not to do the work.

There are many lawyers out there who will work pro bono, figuring it won’t bankrupt them and its for the greater good. There are also legal advocates who charge little or nothing. But it isn't a sustainable model - how long would you work without being paid?

What can I do if I want to get involved?

There are a number of ways to get involved in the consultation and to give your views to  before 1st November - yes, we know they haven't given us much time but don't let that stop you.

  • You can email your views to [email protected]
  • Maxwell Gillott have written about the changes and have also produced a draft letter to write to your MP, which can be downloaded at the end of their post on the proposed changes.
  • There is an online feedback here with all the information, though reading the MG information may help first

Please read about this issues so you are informed and, if you are able, follow up and have your say.

Follow me

Debs Aspland

Exec Director at Bringing Us Together
Mum of 3, wife of 1, Exec Director of Bringing Us Together, Owner of Inspiring Circles, Writer of Chaos in Kent, Development - South at Community Circles
Debs Aspland
Follow me

9 Comments

  1. katie clarke

    this is already happening. we applied for legal aid recently and were turned down whereas we know that a year ago we would have got it. it makes a big difference to who has the control if the LA know that parents cannot afford to challenge.

  2. Given that solicitors charge £100+ an hour, even those of us who don’t qualify for legal aid can’t afford their services. You’d think that market forces would even this out, but it’s the 21st century and I don’t see many cheaper legal services on offer. Justice is for the wealthy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.